1 posts
mark Teacher

Debate Topic: In chapters 19-26 of "One Crazy Summer," should Delphine and her sisters continue to seek a close relationship with their mother, Cecile, despite her cold and distant behavior?

Affirmative Argument:

  • Establishing a relationship with their mother is important for Delphine and her sisters' emotional well-being and sense of family connection. They have the right to know and understand their mother, regardless of her behavior.
  • By spending more time with Cecile and trying to understand her, the sisters might help her open up and eventually form a more loving bond with them.
  • Cecile's cold and distant behavior could be a result of her personal struggles and past experiences. It is important for the sisters to show compassion and empathy, as their efforts might positively influence Cecile's attitude towards them.

Negative Argument:

  • Pursuing a relationship with Cecile could potentially cause more harm than good for Delphine and her sisters, as her behavior might continue to hurt their feelings and affect their self-esteem.
  • The sisters' emotional well-being should be their priority, and if Cecile's behavior is causing them emotional distress, it might be better for them to focus on their relationship with each other and with their father, who has been their primary caregiver.
  • It is not the responsibility of Delphine and her sisters to fix their mother or force a relationship. If Cecile is unwilling to engage with them or show affection, it might be healthier for the sisters to accept the situation and focus on other positive relationships in their lives.

2023-03-24

This account can not be reply